Scene for the next one at the bottom.
This just goes to show how only a little planning and thinking ahead can go a long way. Instead of just randomly entering some building, I spent a few days finding appropriate victims, observing them and making sure no one else was at home, as evidenced by the lack of cars in the driveway and light behind closed curtains in a single window.
As I enter the bedroom I find exactly the three girls I was expecting, all easily identified thanks to the painfully badly-protected school records. The oldest, green-eyed redhead Nicole is naked save for a bra that does little to hide her huge breasts despite her slim and short statue. She's lying on the bed, with her girlfriend's head buried in her crotch, but as soon as she hears me the black-haired girl pulls away and gets up, confirming her as ostensibly Asian Yuming, her breasts still large, but a bit more in line with her slender frame, and she's wearing a black bra and panties, as well as glasses.
“W-what are you doing here?” Lastly, Nicole's younger sister, Amber, shares the hair and eye color with her sister, but hers is much shorter, and she's still much more girl-like than the other two, with a petite figure, as well as the anime motif on her t-shirt.
All three girls start screaming and trying to back away as soon as they notice the gun I'm holding, and after giving them a few moments to panic, I gesture them to be silent and wait for them to – kind of – calm down. “Do exactly as I say, and I may let you live. If not, well...” I raise the pistol and mime shooting myself “Bang. For starters, you two get naked, and you come over here.” I gesture at Amber and she hesitantly obeys.
I pull up her t-shirt to find she isn't wearing a bra even though her breasts are already clearly noticeable, and when I squeeze them, they're nice and firm. Amber shudders under my touch, but when I indicate her take the t-shirt off completely she complies, baring her youthful body that's just barely beginning to gain a womanly shape. I lift her skirt, revealing some hot pink panties and she predictably squirms and shies away, but doesn't do anything to stop me from pulling them down around her ankles, and steps out of them, but when I brush a finger against her perfectly smooth pussy and just lightly push into her she jumps back with a squeak, falling over and landing on the bed.
“You were going to have lesbian sex with her, weren't you?”
“Y-yes...” Nicole answers after several seconds.
“Then you better get started.” I point at Amber “You're gonna get a taste of pussy by eating her” I indicate Yuming “out. ...Do it!” I impatiently add after a few seconds, and Yuming lies on the bed on her back, holding her legs wide apart as Nicole takes Amber's hand to gently guide her to place her face between her girlfriend's legs and give her a few whispered instructions.
After giving them a handful of seconds in the interest of fairness, I grab Nicole's arm to pull her away and force her onto her knees in front of me as I open my trousers to pull out my dick, then sit on the huge office chair to give her a better angle. “Put your tits to use. If you don't make me cum before your sister does to your girlfriend, you're dead.”
With a fearful expression Nicole holds her tits between her hands and places them around my dick; they're huge and warm and soft, and may even be all-natural; if it's implants they're at least very high-quality. Over on the bed Yuming lets out a loud moan, and Nicole quickly starts moving her tits up and down my dick to make up for the head start the others had.
As Nicole continues, I look over to the bed to see Yuming panting heavily, her face flush, holding Amber's head against her pussy with both hands. Apparently Nicole notices too, as she drips some spit on my dick for lubrication and speeds up her movements, even starting to put her lips around the tip with every motion.
Soon enough I feel like I'm about to cum, but from the sounds of it, so is Yuming; this is gonna be close. And Nicole knows it, as she keeps working my dick even faster, the utter fear in her face as hot as little else.
...Here I go. I climax, shooting a huge load all over Nicole's tits and face as she flinches back, and before I'm even done, Yuming comes too, letting out a series of loud moans before slowly winding down panting. Nicole was briefly distracted by the show, but I nudge her shoulder, pulling my dick back a little. “Hey, clean me up.” She obeys, taking my dick as far in her mouth as it will go and running her tongue all around it before pulling back. “Now swallow.” It takes her a few moments and a visible conscious effort to do so, shuddering at the sensation.
“All three, get up.” They all line up in front of the bed, Amber's hair messy and her face slightly wet, Yuming still flush and panting a little, and Nicole's front covered in cum. “You won,” I point at Nicole “That means the other two lose. So you get two decide which of the two losers dies.”
“What? You said you'd let us go!”
“I said I might
. And I think I changed my mind. We'll be playing games until one of you lives. You've got good odds right now, so tell me which of the other two is out.”
“N-no, I- ...Kill me instead.”
“Nicky, no! Don't-”
“How heroic. But I don't think so. You're safe for the moment. Now tell me who's gonna die, your sister or your girlfriend. If you don't decide I'm just gonna shoot them both. And then you too, probably.”
“No, this is- I...”
“Tick tock. Time's running out. Decide or you're all done for.”
“What was that? You need to speak louder.”
“I- Shoot Yuming, just let my sister live!”
“Why didn't you say so?” The Asian's face barely has time to reflect the utter betrayal before I shoot her in the stomach and she doubles over with a pained expression as Amber shrieks at the sudden noise and stumbles backwards onto the bed and Nicole starts hysterically sobbing and muttering 'sorry's.
There's a puddle of blood starting to form under Yuming, but she's clearly still alive, twitching, whimpering and occasionally coughing. “Oh dear, I must have missed that shot, it looks like your friend is in a lot of pain right now.” I turn to Amber “You know fully well it's your fault, if you'd been better at eating pussy you two would have won. She's done for anyways, but surely you want her suffering to be over quickly, don't you?”
Amber slowly nods. “Then there's something you can do for her.” I pick up a pair of dildos lying on the floor next to the bed. “If you can get both of these inside you, I'll consider putting Yuming out of her misery.”
I toss them to her and Amber nods, inspecting the plastic for a moment before laying on her back and carefully inserting the first one into her pussy, letting out a low moan as it enters her, but keeps pushing until it's in almost to the base. Looks like she used one before, this was too easy. But after trying a few times to fit the second dildo in besides, she gives up “There's no way two are gonna fit.”
“Maybe not. But you have an asshole too, don't you? Use it.”
“Never heard of anal sex? It's great. And it looks like your friend is in a lot of pain right now.” To underline my point I kick Yuming in the side and she lets out a loud whimper. “So you better try it.”
Amber tries from a lying position a few more times before wising up and placing the dildo upright onto the bed and very carefully lowering herself onto it. One can perfectly see the moment the tips presses against her asshole as she pauses and hesitantly tries to keep pushing, taking a lot of conscious effort until it slides into her and she winces.
She tries to keep pushing the dildo deeper, but around the halfway point Amber stops with a pained expression and it looks like she's about to give up – when suddenly Nicole is standing next to her, pushing her little sister down and Amber lets out a scream as the dildo fills her ass entirely, tears forming in her eyes.
“Th-there!” Nicole says “Now help Yumie!”
“I only ever said I was going to put her out of her misery.” I grab Yuming's arm to pull her up and she staggers to her feet, and I place my gun right against her forehead, then shoot, a huge jet of blood splashing over the bed, the wall behind it – and Amber, whose expression freezes in shock as Yuming's body goes limp instantly and I just drop her to the ground.
And then there were two. I stow my pistol and take out a piece of wire, walking around the bed until I'm standing right behind Amber, wrapping the wire around her neck and pulling it tight, eliciting a loud gasp as she reflexively reaches for her neck and Nicole screams. “Amber!”
“If you want to save her, make her cum before she passes out. Better be fast.” It takes a few seconds for Nicole to process before she kneels down in front of the bed, pulls the dildo out of Amber's pussy and quickly starts going down on her. Amber's face is already red and she's kicking and gasping beautifully, but Nicole is doing her best too, her face practically buried in her sister's crotch, and from the movement of her arms she's probably using the dildo in her ass too; I wonder if that's gonna be enough.
Amber's struggles keep amping up, before they start slowing down again as she runs out of energy, yet her gasps have an almost rhythmic quality to them in time with Nicole's movements, so clearly she's putting in work too. Just a little later with a loud gasp Amber's eyes roll back, but just moments later her whole body starts rhythmically shuddering and she lets out a series of rattles that I'm pretty sure would have been moans if she'd had any air. That counts, I suppose.
I quickly loosen the wire and pull it away to leave an angry red line around her neck, but a few moments later Amber starts coughing and gasping for breath, her face still red and smudged with tears and drool as her eyes regain focus.
I give Nicole just a few more seconds of fleeting hope before I step up behind her. “You easily could have let her die right there, but you didn't. That means she wins, and you lose. You know what that means.”
“Y...yes.” Looks like she's actually accepting her fate, all for her younger sister, how noble. Nicole looks up, completely baring her neck and not even trying to resist as I wrap the wire around it, half hoisting her onto her feet as I pull it taut.
Her brave facade breaks within seconds as her instincts kick in and Nicole futilely reaches for her neck, her legs kicking over the ground but finding no purchase. “Nicky, no!” Amber has regained awareness enough to start crying, completely powerless to do anything to stop me as her older sister's reply is reduced to a voiceless gasp.
This time I'm strangling her with full force and it doesn't take nearly as long for Nicole to weaken, her eyes bloodshot and her tongue hanging out, and soon her struggles die down to be replaced by weak shudders before she goes completely limp with one last drawn-out rattle, a stream of urine dripping down her legs as she soils herself.
I hold her a good few seconds more before dropping the body on the floor next to her girlfriend's, putting away the wire again as I turn to Amber. “You sister sacrificed both her girlfriend and herself for you, I haven't seen that happen often, you should be thankful.”
“W-will you let me go now?”
“Maybe. We'll just play one final game. Come here.” Amber gets off the bed and I push her onto her knees in front of me “Open up.” I push my dick inside her mouth, then grab the back of her head and force my dick all the way into the back of her throat as she makes a gagging noise and tries to get away, but of course I'm stronger, easily holding her in place.
After just a handful more moments I let go and Amber pulls away, gasping for air as I pull her up and throw her onto the bed. As I force apart her legs she reflexively closes them, but then seems to remember her life is on the line and opens them up on her own, baring her still wet pussy to me.
I push into her, and she draws in a sharp breath. Amber's pussy is nice and tight, and clenches around my dick with every small shiver of hers. So I start quickly and brutally fucking her, and her eyes tear up as she starts whimpering before starting to downright sob. As I continue raping her, part of her expression goes blank and she's just vacantly staring at the ceiling; I suppose all that just happened was enough to break her.
But I think we can do better. I slow down and pull out of Amber, then grab the dildo that was still stuck in her ass, and after shaking it a few times pull that out too as Amber squeaks in pain. But she's too in shock right now to even resist as I press my dick against her asshole and after carefully probing it a few times push in all the way as she lets out a scream and starts crying again.
As I start fucking her in the ass, I notice just how cute Amber is, especially with her face red and stained with tears and her whole body trembling in pain and fear. I clearly can't spare an eyewitness and let her go, but I think I'll take her with me. This may be a bit of work to set up, but I think it's gonna be worth it.
I'm about to cum again, and briefly consider the ages-old porn cliché of pulling out at the last second to give Amber a facial, but I'll have enough opportunities for that later; so for now I just pick up speed, and then abruptly punch Amber in the stomach, and as she gasps for air her asshole clenches around my dick and I cum, shooting my load up her ass.
After winding down a little I pull out, leaving a bit of cum dripping from her asshole for the classic creampie as I grab Amber's arm to pull her up. “Congratulations, you won. You get to live. Now come with me and let's get out of here.” The redhead is still in shock and just goes along with it as I throw my jacket over her to somewhat cover her up for the way to my car, then take her hand and pull her with me, on the way dialing the number of that crime scene cleaner who still owes me a favor.